Roasting pans

Roasting pans compared by size, turkey capacity, oven limit and stove, as each maker states them: clad stainless pans with racks, none with a lid.

3 products, most cooking jobs covered first

On this page

Will it fit your oven, and your stove?

Measure inside your oven before you buy: with their handles these pans run 18.3 to 18.5 inches long. All-Clad's D3 is 16¾ by 13¾ inches in the body and holds up to a 20 lb turkey. Made In says its pan fits a 24 lb turkey. Demeyere gives 8.45 quarts and no turkey size.

Making the gravy on the stove afterwards? On induction only Demeyere's works. All-Clad's works on gas, electric and glass tops; Made In rules out induction for its flared bottom and names no other stove. In the oven, All-Clad and Made In rate theirs to 600°F and Demeyere to 500°F, and All-Clad and Demeyere allow the broiler. Demeyere's may go in the dishwasher; All-Clad's is hand wash only, and Made In recommends washing by hand. Demeyere's rack is nonstick-coated, so keep metal tools off it.

Sizes and weights, as the makers give them

Only each maker’s own figures are shown, and a figure it doesn’t give reads “Not stated”. Tap a heading to sort.

Each maker's own figures, pan by pan
All-Clad D3 Stainless Large Flared Roaster with Rack and Two Turkey Forks, 13 x 16 in2.5 in18.5 in13.7 in20 lbNot stated6.96 lbNot included
Demeyere Industry 5 Roasting Pan with rack, 487403.15 in18.31 in13.78 inNot stated8.45 US qt9.37 lbNot included
Made In Stainless Clad Roasting Pan with Rack5.98 in18.46 in12.5 in24 lbNot stated10.01 lbNot included

Compare them side by side

Scroll sideways for every column; tap a heading to sort. “Not stated” means the maker doesn’t publish it.

Contents, cooking jobs and model-specific limits
All-Clad D3 Stainless Large Flared Roaster with Rack and Two Turkey Forks, 13 x 16 inStainless clad1 / 0Roasting panDoesn't work on induction600 °F / No lidHand wash only
Demeyere Industry 5 Roasting Pan with rack, 48740Stainless clad1 / 0Roasting panWorks on induction500 °F / No lidDishwasher safe
Made In Stainless Clad Roasting Pan with RackStainless clad1 / 0Roasting panDoesn't work on induction600 °F / No lidMaker doesn't say if it's dishwasher safe; handwashing recommended

Questions before you choose

How are these products ordered?

Products that cover more everyday cooking jobs come first, then those with more pots and pans, then more lids, then by name. It is not a quality ranking, and what we earn from a link never changes the order.

What does “Not stated” mean?

The maker does not publish that figure for this exact product. It does not mean there is no limit; ask the maker or pick a product that states it.

Share this page

The link opens this page. Anything you've typed or saved stays on your device.